1870 W Lake Road
Skaneateles Lake Great Estate

An unprecedented offering on Skaneateles Lake, this estate features nearly 412 feet of pristine lake frontage and 3.98 acres of land on Mandana Bay, often called the Hamptons of the Finger Lakes. Comprising two separate parcels (building lot valued at 2.9 million and estate home valued at $5.9 million), the property is offered together at $8.8 million at the owner’s request. The expansive setting allows for the construction of an additional residence for guests and space for amenities such as a tennis court. Rarely does a property of this scale and potential become available on Skaneateles Lake.

At the request of the broker, interior photography has been intentionally withheld. The interiors must be experienced in person to fully appreciate the quality, design, and sense of place they offer. Private showings are available by appointment only for qualified buyers.

MANDANA SHORES

1870 & 1860 W Lake Road | Skaneateles, NY

Along the most coveted shoreline of Skaneateles Lake, renowned as one of the purest lakes in the world, two contiguous parcels unite to form a once-in-a-generation legacy offering. Encompassing approximately 3.98 acres with an extraordinary expanse of rare, level waterfront, this estate is presented at $8.8 million and invites its next steward to shape a compound of enduring significance.

Property Offering

  • 3.98 acres across 2 tax parcels (1870 & 1860 West Lake Road)

  • Approximately 412 feet of private, level Skaneateles Lake shoreline

  • Two grandfathered boathouses, one on each parcel

  • Main residence at 1870 W Lake Road: c.1930, approx. 5,281 sq. ft., 6 bedrooms, 3 full bathroom, 1 half bathroom

  • Attached 2 car garage

  • Carriage house garage for flexible use

  • Just 5.5 miles (approx. 10 minutes) from the Skaneateles Village Pier

A Historic Lakeside Residence

At 1870 West Lake Road, a c.1930 residence of more than 5,000 square feet stands ready for its next chapter. The home retains elements of its historic charm including hardwood floors, pocket doors, and a wraparound porch that frames sweeping lake views. With generous proportions, multiple fireplaces, and a carriage house, the property offers a rare framework upon which to create a truly bespoke estate. Paired with an attached and detached garage and a grandfathered boathouse anchoring its deep-water frontage, this parcel presents an extraordinary opportunity to reimagine one of Skaneateles Lake’s most sought-after addresses.

A Vacant Parcel of Pure Potential

Immediately adjoining, at 1860 West Lake Road, 2.05 acres of level waterfront land offers the ultimate canvas for expansion. Complete with its own grandfathered boathouse and unobstructed water views, the parcel may serve as a private retreat, a guest residence site, or a multi-generational extension of the estate.

 

A Legacy on Skaneateles Lake

Together, these parcels present a rare alignment of history, architecture, and possibility. With nearly 412 feet of level lakefront, multiple boathouses, and the capacity to create a multi-structure compound, the estate stands as a generational opportunity on one of the Northeast’s most celebrated lakes. Just minutes from the village of Skaneateles, with its vibrant cultural life and easy access to regional hubs, this property is as convenient as it is extraordinary.

An offering of this scale and character is exceptionally scarce, positioned not only as a residence, but as a legacy estate destined to endure for generations.

 

Hallmarks of This Irreplaceable Skaneateles Lake Estate

·       Rare Level Shoreline - A gently sloping, walk-out waterfront that invites effortless enjoyment of the lake.

·       Two Grandfathered Boathouses- Architectural treasures preserved by time, offering privileges no longer granted today.

·       Dual Parcel Flexibility- Two separate tax parcels provide the framework for a generational compound or the preservation of unmatched privacy.

·       Expansive Private Frontage – Approximately 412 feet of pristine shoreline on one of the purest lakes in the world.

·       Close to Village Life- Just 5.5 miles from the Skaneateles Pier, blending lakeside serenity with immediate access to dining, shopping, and cultural pursuits.

·       Legacy Investment- Properties of this scale and character rarely come to market, securing both a lifestyle and a heritage for future generations.